Scholar athletes** Two-Time NAIA Scholar Athlete | Year | Name | Award |
|---|
| 2009 | Curt Bomgaars | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 2009 | Matt Gray | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 2009 | Trevor Kuiper** | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 2008 | Blake Kruger | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 2008 | Trevor Kuiper** | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 2007 | Kent Wallinga | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 2004 | Nick Harthoorn | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 2000 | Eric Vermeer | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 1999 | Shane Jager | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | | Ben Lacey | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 1998 | Matt Trost | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | | Shane Jager | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 1997 | Eric Vermeer | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 1996 | Trygve Johnson | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 1995 | Trygve Johnson | NAIA Scholar Athlete | | 1980 | Jim Boeve | NAIA Scholar Athlete CoSida Award |
|